Book Description
Wellington's celebrated Peninsular army played a vital role in the defeat of Napoleon's French forces in Portugal and Spain. It is one of the most famous armies in military history. Yet the last large-scale examination of its structure and operation was written by Sir Charles Oman as long ago as 1913, and since then so much new material has come to light that a fresh account is long overdue.
This important new study, which uses Oman's pioneering work as a foundation, provides a wide-ranging survey of the latest research into the subject, and it is a major contribution to the history of the Peninsular War.
Customer Reviews:
Inside Wellington's Peninsular army.......2007-10-11
I was looking for a book that would finally offer me insight in the quality of the men and officers of this army, optimistic from the fact that Rory Muir is one of the authors.
Instead I found so much paper and no opinion. To describe a general by listing his qualifications, tells me nothing. Same for the units.
Disappointing book for me.
One for the Dedicated Student.......2007-06-23
The exploits of Wellington's Peninsular Army in Portugal, Spain, and Southern France during 1808-1814 are justly famous and have been rather thoroughly explored by a variety of scholars and popular historians. It is therefore a genuine pleasure when a book advertising new research and new insights actually lives up to its billing.
"Inside Wellington's Peninsular Army 1808-1814" contains seven essays and a special appendix, authored by four writers, the most prominent being Rory Muir. Muir provides the introductory essay, a well-written summary of the importance of Wellington and his army to the conflict. Ron McGuigan explores the ad hoc nature of the "disposable force" that became the British core of Wellington's army in the second essay. In the third essay, Robert Burnham provides a brief description of intelligence-gathering activities by selected British officers.
The fourth essay, by Howie Muir, may be the most interesting to students of the Peninsular War. In it, Muir captures how the seniority of British units and of commanders drove an habitual spatial placement of units on the battlefield, literally their "order of battle." This habitual arrangement, nowadays used only for formal parades, once served as the standard operating procedure for ordering units in and out of combat. In an army guided by voice command and couriers, this procedure imparted necessary predictability, and its use provides insight into how several battle unfolded during the Peninsular War. Muir uses Talavera, Albuera, and Toulouse as case studies. As an example, Muir's finding offers a plausible explanation for why Major General Stewart's 2nd Divisions took an hour to reposition itself at Albuera over an distance that represented perhaps a 15 minute walk. Muir's essay provides insight into the perogatives of rank and Wellington's requirement to carefully manage the placement of senior officers. Ron McGuigan's follow-on essay notes the general officers who served with Wellington and the units with which they were habitually associated.
Robert Burnham describes the British Army's challenges in keeping the ranks of Wellington's army filled and its experimentation with various more or less innovative solutions. This particular essay has some relevance for an American Army striving to keep sufficient forces deployed in Iraq and Afghanistan. In a separate essay, Burnham notes the remarkable bridging work done by British engineers in a theater of war with few permanent bridges and limited building materials. A closing appendix lists the memoirs associated with the British units that served in Portugal and Spain.
This book is very highly recommended to the dedicated student of the British Army and its participation in the Peninsular War. This volume is not obviously meant to be popular history for the general reader, who may find the material less interesting and difficult to follow.
A One of a Kind Book.......2007-06-18
If you're like me, you've gotten tired of the Napoleonic books that simply rehash the same subjects, regurgitating the same information from the same sources. You've probably felt that pang of disappointment and wasted money when you've ordered a `new' book on say Waterloo, only to find the very same accounts with the very same pictures from another publisher. If so, I know you will find INSIDE WELLINGTON'S ARMY an exciting and refreshing change. If you are longing for new research, a deeper understanding, and broader perspectives on the Peninsular war, then INSIDE WELLINGTON'S ARMY is the answer.
INSIDE WELLINTON'S ARMY is a unique series of studies, providing research on important and misunderstood topics not found anywhere else. The book's stated purpose is to supplement existing histories, particularly Oman's 1913 study "Wellington's Army 1809-1814", which offered a distillation of much what Oman had learned while researching his multi-volume work on the history of the Peninsular war. The authors have succeeded admirably.
The seven substantial chapters cover such topics as the origin of Wellington's army in the Peninsula. By the end of the war, Wellington commanded the largest British army in history, for far longer than any other expeditionary force. The how's and why's of its creation explains a great deal, not only why Wellington could win so consistently with the army, but also British military thinking and organization for the rest of the Nineteenth Century.
The Chapters on British feats of military bridging and how the British kept their units up to strength provide detailed information, tables and period pictures seen nowhere else. The variety and number of `firsts' in bridging carried out by the British is amazing, as are the numerous original pictures and engineering diagrams provided with the text. Anyone who has read about the Peninsular war knows how important bridging was for the Spanish campaigns, but this is the first it has been written about in any detail, let alone the lush data provided in the book.
The chapter on the British Army's `order of battle', is equally fascinating, a must for anyone interested in the military practices of the day. This study of the system used to organize an army in a battle line during the Peninsular war reveals how the place of honor and seniority provided the structure for movement, battle, morale and discipline. This often misunderstood set of practices dictated who would command what units where in the battle line, providing a set of structural tools for an army commander in creating a winning set of battle tactics. This system of custom and is examined in detail, it's practicality and uses in the field, as well as the continuity in operations that the Peninsular army shared with those armies that went before and after it. And of course, the same methods used for a `customary battle-array' by the British were very similar to those of other nations during the Napoleonic wars.
The authors have spent years of study to produce their individual chapters, offering a depth of knowledge and wealth of information found in few other works on the British army and the Peninsular war. If you are looking for some more than `the same-old, same-old' in Napoleonic history, you can't go wrong with INSIDE WELLINGTON'S ARMY.
Average customer rating:
- The final phase of the Peninsular War
|
Wellington Invades France: The Final Phase of the Peninsular War 1813-1814
Ian Robertson
Manufacturer: Greenhill Books
ProductGroup: Book
Binding: Hardcover
General
| Europe
| History
| Subjects
| Books
General
| France
| Europe
| History
| Subjects
| Books
General
| England
| Europe
| History
| Subjects
| Books
19th Century
| England
| Europe
| History
| Subjects
| Books
General
| Ireland
| Europe
| History
| Subjects
| Books
General
| Military
| History
| Subjects
| Books
General
| Napoleonic Wars
| Military
| History
| Subjects
| Books
19th Century
| World
| History
| Subjects
| Books
General
| World
| History
| Subjects
| Books
ASIN: 1853675342 |
Book Description
A detailed account of Wellington's campaign in the south of France. Drawing on eyewitness accounts and official dispatches, Ian Robertson outlines the nature of the war as well as traces the complicated maneuvering and operations of the British and French armies. He describes in detail such hard-fought actions as the Nivelle, Orthez, Toulouse, and Bayonne and throws light on some less well-known clashes, many of which were fought in the unforgiving terrain of the Pyrenees.
Customer Reviews:
The final phase of the Peninsular War.......2005-01-24
Ian C. Robertson's "Wellington Invades France" provides a detailed account of the final year (1813-1814) of the British campaign to evict Imperial French forces from Spain and then to complete the military defeat of Napoleon by invading France. Ian Robertson is well-versed in the era and has a number of books to his credit on this general topic. This particular history is so detailed as to be a very daunting read to all but the most dedicated student of the British Army in the Peninsular War. The prose tends to be very dry, although it is supported by nicely chosen quotes by witnesses to the campaign and by clear diagrams of the actual battles. The interpretation of events is fairly standard. The casual reader without background in the Napoleonic Wars will find this a challenging read.
Average customer rating:
- The Conclusion of the Peninsular War
- The Complete Story
|
A History of the Peninsular War Volume VII: August 1813 to April 14,1814: St Sebastian's Capture,Wellington's Invasion (History of the Peninsular War)
Sir Charles Oman
Manufacturer: Greenhill Books
ProductGroup: Book
Binding: Paperback
General
| Europe
| History
| Subjects
| Books
Western
| Europe
| History
| Subjects
| Books
General
| Military
| History
| Subjects
| Books
Strategy
| Military
| History
| Subjects
| Books
19th Century
| World
| History
| Subjects
| Books
General
| World
| History
| Subjects
| Books
Similar Items:
-
A History of the Peninsular War V6: September 1,1812 to August 5,1813 The Seige of Burgos,The Retreat from Burgos,The Ca (History of the Peninsular War)
-
A History of the Peninsular War V5: October 1811 to August 31, 1812 Alencia,Cuidad Rodrigo,Badajoz,Salamanca,Madrid (History of the Peninsular War)
-
A History of the Peninsular War Volume IV: December 1810-December 1811 Massena's Retreat,Fuentes de Onoro,Albuera
-
A History of the Peninsular War Volume II: January to September 1809 from the Battle of Corunna to the End (History of the Peninsular War)
-
A History of the Peninsular War Volume III: September 1809-December 1810 Ocana,Cadiz,Bussaco,Torres Vedras (History of the Peninsular War)
ASIN: 1853676632 |
Book Description
Between August 1813 and the end of hostilities in April 1814, Napoleon's forces were finally expelled from the Iberian Peninsula. Wellington's army invaded southern France, only halting its operations when news was received of Napoleon's abdication. The events covered in this volume include the British siege and capture of St Sebastian; the final campaigning in eastern Spain; Wellington's invasion of France; and the last actions of the war in the Battle of Toulouse and the French sortie from Bayonne. A chapter on the place of the Peninsular War in history concludes Oman's monumental work.
Customer Reviews:
The Conclusion of the Peninsular War.......2005-10-04
This is the wonderfully affordable paperback version of Volume VII of Charles Oman's definitive study of the Peninsular War. In it, the Duke of Wellington, at the head of an Anglo-Portuguese-Spanish Army, crosses the French border as part of a larger Allied coalition campaign to end Napoleon's reign as Empereor of France. Wellington's campaign is paced by the on-again, off-again negotiations between Napoleon and the Coalition. A series of victories by Wellington's Army over the forces of French Marshal Soult are therefore never quite decisive. Wellington's Army, in addition, faced formidable challenges conducting an offensive inside France over difficult terrain and against a nominally hostile population. However, Wellington's task is made easier by Marshal Soult's seeming inability to manage his army in close combat, and by the slow wasting of what had once been a veteran French Army, as enthusiasm for Napoleon begins to dwindle.
Oman's mastery of his subject and of his prose is complete. The narrative flows smoothly. His retelling of the second siege of San Sebastian is remarkably vivid, capturing both the heroism and the horror of the final Allied storming of that fortress. His account of the confusing multi-day Battle of the Nive is clear and easy to follow. Oman highlights the remarkable tenacity of British and Portuguese infantry battalions that withstood a series of French counterattacks at unequal odds. Oman's narrative of the campaign across southern France is clearer than any other studies this reader is familiar with.
The primary focus of this book is the confrontation between Wellington's Army and the French Army under Marshal Soult. However, Oman does not neglect the campaign in Catalonia or the political background to the last nine months of the Peninsular War. Oman includes a nice concluding essay about the fates of the more prominent generals after the war, as well as an acknowledgement of the messy end of the conflict in Spain.
In this volume, the last of seven, Oman assumes that readers are already familiar with the history of the Peninsular War up through the fall of 1813 and the Battle of the Pyrenees. Oman does not recap the story, nor does he reintroduce personalities from earlier volumes. There is just a slight sense that Oman was pushing to finish a project that had already taken nearly thirty years.
This volume and series are highly recommended to dedicated readers of the Peninsular War and the Napoleonic era. The casual reader without background in the conflict may find this volume the wrong place to start.
The Complete Story.......2005-05-24
Sir Charles Oman's comprehensive seven volume history of the Peninsular War is the yardstick by which any other history of this theatre must be measured. It is exhaustive in detail and in breadth of coverage. If it happened, it is in one of these volumes. Napoleon may have considered Spain a side show, but as results turned out it was a bleeding ulcer. French losses here, combined with the 1812 campaign, placed a strain on the Empire which could not be overcome by even the best generalship. Any true student of the Napoleonic Wars should find these books and read them. They are essential to a complete understanding of the conflict.
Book Description
With Wellington's Light Cavalry - Campaigning with the 16th Light Dragoons in the Peninsular and Waterloo Campaigns of the Napoleonic Wars. A cavalryman's story that could have ended before it began. In the first chapter Tomkinson and his 16th Light Dragoons rashly charge into the rearguard of the French Army and he is shot and bayoneted. But in 1810 Tomkinson is once again in Spain fighting the French. This book is a fine example of a personal account filled with personal and unit detail combined with a clear and informative narrative of the campaigns in which the writer was engaged. A substantial read by any standards, the final 55 pages are devoted to Tompkinson's first hand experience of the 1815 campaign culminating in Napoleon's downfall at Waterloo.
Book Description
'If anyone wishes to know the history of this war, I will tell them that it is our maritime superiority gives me the power of maintaining my army while the enemy are unable to do so.' Wellington's remark reveals that he fully appreciated the strategic importance of the naval support for his campaign, but up to now this crucial aspect of the Peninsular War has been largely ignored, except where there were overt naval contributions to battles and sieges. As this new book amply demonstrates, the maritime dimension was far broader, and stretched from the very start of the military intervention to the final days of Wellington's invasion of southern France. The Navy not only transported the armies to the theatre - and evacuated them when required, as at Corunna - but also provided direct support to the land campaigns in terms of heavy gun crews at sieges, and also tied down large numbers of enemy troops by diversionary attacks on coastal targets. But the biggest contribution was less visible, though arguably the most significant: in order not to lose local support, Wellington refused to let his army live off the land as the French had done, so all provisions - food, clothing and arms - were supplied from the sea. This was an enormous undertaking, involving nearly 1000 ships (or about 10 per cent of the British merchant marine) which had to be convoyed and protected. Furthermore, local financial support had to be paid in hard currency, so the Navy also took responsibility for moving vast quantities of specie to the Peninsula, tying up valuable warships in the process. This important new book is the first full study of the workings of sea power in the campaign, from operations to the complexities of logistics and administration. It is significant reading for naval and military historians alike.
Customer Reviews:
A Study of Often Neglected Naval Operations.......2007-03-21
Christopher Hall's "Wellington's Navy: Sea Power and the Peninsular War, 1807-1814" is not a story of great fleet actions or dramatic single-ship frigate actions. Although the Royal Navy forces operating on the coasts of Portugal and Spain in this period engaged from time to time in blockading French-occupied ports or conducting cutting out expeditions, more often it was a long war of convoys and transportation of supplies and money and troops -- and sometimes supporting regular and guerilla forces with direct artillery fire. British sailors and marines were sent ashore to man guns and to participate in land assaults and to construct fortifications and bridges. In short, the Royal Navy performed just about any sort of duty demanded of it, playing a crucial role in bringing the Peninsular War to an ultimately successful conclusion, winning Wellington's praise and respect. Coordinating activities with thin-skinned Spanish officials and erratic guerilla leaders were continuing challenges, but something the Royal Navy learned to take it all in stride.
Hall's book tells this unfamilar story well, a worthy complement to volumes dealing with great sea battles and glamorous frigate actions.
A Book for the Specialist.......2006-06-20
"Wellington's Navy" is Christopher Hall's indepth examination of the key supporting role played by the British Navy in the liberation of the Iberian Peninsula from Imperial French control during 1807-1814.
Numerous authors have acknowledged the superb mobility provided to Wellington's Army in the Peninsula by the British Navy. Hall documents the British Navy's success in regularly moving forces and supplies to Portugal and Spain by sea without French interdiction, and while denying the same degree of mobility to the French. Especially important was the role of the British Fleet providing operational mobility around a theater of war surrounded, as Hall notes, on three and a half sides by water. The British Fleet enabled Wellington's entry into Portugal in 1808, evacuated Sir John Moore's surrounded army from Corunna in 1809, provided an escape option for Wellington's Lines of Torres Vedras in 1810, and enabled Wellington to shift his lines of communication to northern Spain in 1813. In between these major events, the British Navy blockaded French-held ports, escorted Portuguese and Spanish trade, and provided gunfire support ashore. Individual British captains and squadron commanders displayed remarkable initiative in working with local Spanish leaders to harass and confound the French occupation forces.
"Wellington's Navy" represents an impressive degree of research into a portion of the Peninsular Wars that gets light coverage in most histories. His list of sources will be of interest to the specialist in this period.
Hall's narrative may be a challenge for the casual reader. He writes in a serviceable but undramatic style. He does assume a working knowledge of the British Navy's ships and tactics of the period, of the land campaigns of the Peninsular Wars, and of the larger strategic struggle against Napoleon on the part of the reader. Hall does not provide a primer on naval matters, and makes only passing reference to the larger Naval strategy against Napoleon. The breakdown of naval operations in Spain during 1810-1814 follows a primarily geographic rather than chronological order, which may make it difficult to understand the full context of each event.
This book is recommended to the student of the Peninsular Wars, and may be best read in conjunction with one of the comprehensive histories, such as Oman's dated but still excellent seven volume narrative.
Book Description
A Must for Peninsular War enthusiasts and all those interested in the famous green Riflemen Captain Leach brings his military experiences during the Napoleonic Wars into sharp relief. We share the rigours of campaigning and dangers of the battlefield, but his descriptions of the events in the broader military scene and his description of the country through which he journeys assist in bringing the era to life for everyone interested in the adventures of this famous regiment and its men.
Customer Reviews:
A true life story popularised by a British Television Series.......1997-04-08
After reading Cornwells series of books about Richard Sharpe and then reading 'A British Rifleman' you can see startling comparisons between the two. Cornwells series have recently been made into a television series in the UK and it is likely that he drew upon George Simmons' book for inspiration.
.
Having read the 1st edition of A British Rifleman, published in 1899, and being in the Australian Army myself, you cannot begin to draw comparisons between service today and that of 100 years ago. The book is about the courage and commitment of a man at a time of bitter struggle between nations. The book exposes the human face to war in the 1800's as Major George Simmons relates his experiences through the medium of personal letters to his family and through his subsequent recollections at the completion of the Penninsula War.
For the military historian or for those who enjoy a good read, this book is a mus
Book Description
The first book to examine in detail the role of one of the most important fortifications in military history, the Lines of Torres Vedras in the Peninsular War, 1809-1812. In 1809 the French armies controlled almost every Spanish province and only Wellington's small force in Portugal stood between Napoleon and the conquest of Iberia. The French invaded Portugal but found their way blocked by the greatest range of field fortifications the world had ever seen - the Lines of Torres Vedras. Unable to penetrate the Lines, the French were driven back into Spain having suffered the heaviest defeat yet experienced by Napoleon's armies. From the security of the Lines, Wellington was then able to mount the offensive campaigns which ultimately brought him victory in the Peninsula. This is an account of the planning, construction and occupation of the Lines and of the battles, sieges and horrors of the French invasion. It is also a challenging new study of Wellington's strategy during the crucial years of the Peninsular War.
Customer Reviews:
Specialized, Detailed, Comprehensive and Unique.......2006-05-04
The most important in enjoying this book, is wanting to know
more about the historical events that shaped the future
of Portugal, and Europe. It's also about wishing to tie-in
the Peninsular War with how the country of Portugal evolved
in the next 100 years, its society, structures, political
allegiances, commercial evolution, etc.
The book is unique, in how it focuses laser-like on the
Peninsular, and specifically, Portuguese - French conflict
fought by the British and Iberian peoples. It also is valuable
in the degree of specialized technical knowledge about the
military that the author shows.
In regards to other potential researchers, hobbyists or
professors of history or at a univeristy, each chapter is
meticulously referenced with supporting documentation and
sources.
There are a number of photos, as well as interesting passages
of correspondence between Napoleon and the commanders in
the field, operating in Portugal and Spain. The same is true
with the Duke of Wellington dealing with his brother, Foreign
Secretary in Britain, and other key players to whom he
had to report to, for spending over 1 million pounds in a year
in a conflict.
Overall, since the book touches upon a real event that impacted
greatly the portuguese population, and how the British
succeeded militarily and financially in the same place where
the Portuguese and Spanish failed, is well worth the price.
I see that the Amazon.co.uk partner of amazon.com may be
offering this book, as well, as a lower price, since it was
published in the UK.
Average customer rating:
- A Companion Volume to Oman's great history of the Peninsular War
|
Wellington's Army 1809-1814
Charles Oman
Manufacturer: Greenhill Books
ProductGroup: Book
Binding: Paperback
General
| Europe
| History
| Subjects
| Books
Spain
| Europe
| History
| Subjects
| Books
General
| England
| Europe
| History
| Subjects
| Books
19th Century
| England
| Europe
| History
| Subjects
| Books
General
| Ireland
| Europe
| History
| Subjects
| Books
General
| Military
| History
| Subjects
| Books
Weapons & Warfare
| Military
| History
| Subjects
| Books
| Biological & Chemical
| Control
| Conventional
| Nuclear
General
| Napoleonic Wars
| Military
| History
| Subjects
| Books
Military Science
| History
| Subjects
| Books
Similar Items:
-
Captain of the 95th (rifles) An officer of Wellington's Sharpshooters during the Peninsular, South of France and Waterloo campaigns of the Napoleonic wars
-
A History of the Peninsular War Volume VII: August 1813 to April 14,1814: St Sebastian's Capture,Wellington's Invasion (History of the Peninsular War)
-
Rifleman Costello: The adventures of a soldier of the 95th (rifles) in the Peninsular & Waterloo Campaigns of the Napoleonic Wars
-
A History of the Peninsular War Volume III: September 1809-December 1810 Ocana,Cadiz,Bussaco,Torres Vedras (History of the Peninsular War)
-
A History of the Peninsular War V6: September 1,1812 to August 5,1813 The Seige of Burgos,The Retreat from Burgos,The Ca (History of the Peninsular War)
ASIN: 1853676772 |
Book Description
This book gives an unparalleled insight into the organization, day-to-day life and psychology of Wellington's army, focusing on the characters that Wellington believed could go anywhere and do anything'. Wellington's Army examines both the leaders and the led; the daily life, manners and customs of the Peninsular Army are explored, drawing on dispatches, general orders and records of court martial, and, to a greater extent, non-official information such as diaries, memoirs and letters. A great deal of literature was produced during this period, written by both commissioned and non-commissioned soldiers. For the soldiers, the campaign became a battle against the Revolution, a kind of crusade, and an attempt to thwart the triple-headed monster of Republicanism, Atheism and Sedition. The soldiers of Wellington's army were fighting for all that made life worth living - religion, morality, constitution, laws and liberty.
Customer Reviews:
A Companion Volume to Oman's great history of the Peninsular War.......2006-04-25
British historian Charles Oman spend thirty years writing "The History of the Peninsular War." Although now somewhat dated, Oman's seven volume study may still be the best English language narrative history of the Peninsular War. Oman chose to include a significant collection of supporting materials on the British Army in a companion volume: "Wellington's Army 1809-1814."
In "Wellington's Army," Oman sketches the leadership, organization, tactics, and details about the life of the long-serving British field army in the Iberian Peninsula. His topics include Wellington's use of his infantry and cavalry, his conduct of supply and of sieges, and the means by which he disciplined his force.
Oman's long immersion in the correspondence and memoirs of the Peninsular Army leads to many worthwhile insights, including why Wellington was respected but not loved by his troops and why his army was so successful for so long against superior numbers of French forces. One example is Wellington's insistance on campaigning from an established supply chain, which allowed his army to remain concentrated in the field far longer than his French adversaries. The French Army of the time depended on forage and pillage for supply, and when concentrated into a large mass, quickly exhausted the available local supplies and was forced to disperse.
Oman provides useful insight into the manning of Wellington's army through the rotation of first and second battalions under the regimental system. An appendix documents why Britain strained to field Wellington's relatively small army in the Peninsula, given the competing demands of the world wide British Empire.
Oman does not spare Wellington's Army its faults. The conduct of siege warfare was never its strong suite. Wellington's force lacked engineers and sometimes the artillery and the time to conduct proper sieges. It was successful at Ciudad Rodrigo and Badajoz thanks to the bravery of its soldiers, not its technique, and failed at Burgos for want of serious preparation.
This book is highly recommended to students of the Peninsular War and of Wellington as a commander. The casual reader with some background in the British Army will also find this a worthwhile book. Oman's writing style is clear and readable. This Greenhill reprint is wonderfully priced and contains a small number of prints and all the excellent appendices of the original.
Book Description
The Battle of Talavera was one of the key confrontations of the Peninsular War. In a bloody contest the British and Spanish under Wellesley and Cuesta won a tactical victory over the French forces of Victor and Joseph Bonaparte. The battle was the climax of the offensive launched by Wellesley and his Spanish allies to expel the French from Madrid.
Andrew Field's graphic analysis is the first full-length reassessment to be published in recent times. Using documentary records, eyewitness accounts and a painstaking study of the terrain, he reconstructs the action in vivid detail and questions assumptions about the event that have grown up over the last 200 years. He also provides an extensive tour of the battlefield.
Customer Reviews:
Bravo Mr. Field!!.......2007-02-20
Finally, an Anglo-Saxon author writes a excellent and honest analysis on the age old column vs. line debate. Field describes in understandable detail the critical points that made the attack column such an effective force against the major European armies: 1) softening the morale and strength at the attack point through concentrated artillery fire in advance of the attack, 2) constant harassing fire from the "cloud of skirmishers" that preceded the attack column, and 3) the coup de grace of the massed column itself threatening an already defeated enemy with the bayonet. He also provides the critical tactics that Wellesley developed through his battles with the French (largely through lessons learned at Talavera) that allowed him to defeat the French attack columns over and over again: 1) sheltering on the reverse slope or lying down, 2) an even deeper "cloud of skirmishers" than the French deployed, 3) a properly trained soldier who was taught to aim correctly rather than just pump off rounds as fast as humanly possible, and 4) a controlled counter attack after the column's momentum had been halted. There is none of the "steady British infantry" rubbish or the superiority of the Brown Bess that fills so many other tomes. Field even goes so far as to say that the British were successful with these tactics, not because they were British, but because of the theater of operations that favored the British and their Allies and was so completely hostile to the French. How utterly refreshing and instructive!!
On the basis of this analysis alone, I recommend this edition to any student of the period.
I was also highly pleased with Field's description of the Spanish armies and their leaders, the dynamics of the regional Juntas and the interplay with their British ally. Again, he drops the jingoistic view that the Spanish were treacherous and unreliable and describes how the patriotic zeal of the Spanish repeatedly drove them to over commit on their ability to perform both in terms of military achievements on the field of battle as well as to provide supplies and support to an alien army which had only a few months before been a traditional enemy of Spain.
I am so pleased to have made this addition to my library.
Overpriced and underwritten book.......2006-10-27
Andrew Field's Talavera reminded me greatly of the Osprey's Campaign series of book. The format is just about the same except this book is about the double of the length.
Field's narrative account of the campaign and battle of Talavera proves to be quite good and readable. I found his battlefield tour section to be quite interesting and he provides a nice order of the battle for both armies.
What I found bit redundant were the first 65 pages of the book where he writes about the armies, tactics and leaders. That is nearly one-third of the book written about stuff that probably only needed third of that space. I write this because Talavera is very specific subject of the Napoleonic Wars. Most Americans have no idea and really, no interest in this battle. Only Napoleonic readers will buy and read this book and we really don't need an heavy section on Wellington or Napoleon and his Marshals, nor do we need a lessons in Napoleonic tactics and formations. An average reader who buy an expensive book like this already got a good understanding of these subjects. What we want is detail study of a battle that haven't been studied in depth in modern period. But instead, while readable and competently written, the campaign and battle accounts inside this book proves to be a quick study. Its what I expect from these Osprey Campaign series.
Thus, I think the book is grossly overpriced and underwritten.
A Closer Look at the Battle of Talavera.......2006-08-06
Andrew Field's "Talavera" is a thoughtful re-examination of the 1809 Battle of Talavara, fought between the Imperial French forces of King Joseph (Napoleon's brother) and a Anglo-Spanish force co-commanded by Arthur Wellesley, later Duke of Wellington. Talavera has been obscured in the historical record by later battles in the Peninsular War, but Field's painstaking narrative explains why the battle is worthy of examination.
Field provides an extended introduction to the battle that identifies the opposing armies and how they came to be at Talavera in western Spain in July of 1809. Of particular note is his methodical discussion of tactics, especially of the longstanding dispute over the relative value of defensive line against attacking column. Field provides some fresh, nuanced insights into this discussion.
Talavera was a narrow tactical victory for the British and Spanish forces. Its outcome established the ability of British infantry to face down their French counterparts and began the slow erosion of French moral ascendency over their battlefield opponents. More importantly, it marked an important step in the education of Arthur Wellesley, whose military reputation to that point rested mainly on his exploits in India against a different class of opponents. Wellesley came to the Peninsula convinced that he could beat the French Army; his hard-won experience at Talavera taught how much more work was required. In later battles, Wellington (as he was known after Talavera)would exercise great care in his selection of ground to protect his troops from French superiority in artillery and cavalry. He would take great pains to ensure his troops were well-supplied. Finally, he would refine his battlefield tactics and training to produce the British Army that ended the French occupation of Spain and invaded France in 1814. By contrast, his French opponents seemed to have learned very little from Talavera.
Field has a solid and serviceable writing style. He has included a small selection of maps and illustrations along with detailed orders of battle in his book. His treatment of the participants is remarkably even-handed, giving due credit to King Joseph for having successfully defended Madrid in the summer of 1809.
This book is highly recommended to students of the Peninsular War and of the British Army in the era of the Napoleonic wars.
Books:
- Invading Mexico: America's Continental Dream and the Mexican War, 1846-1848
- Jack Nastyface: Memoirs of an English Seaman
- Jayne's Intelligence Review - The Royal Manticoran Navy (Honor Harrington)
- JFK: The CIA, Vietnam and the Plot to Assassinate John F. Kennedy
- Landscape Turned Red: The Battle of Antietam
- Leadership and the New Science: Discovering Order in a Chaotic World
- Lone Star Lawmen: The Second Century of the Texas Rangers
- Los Cuatro Acuerdos: Una Guia Practica para la Libertad Personal
- My Name Is America: journal Of Rufus Rowe, Witness To The Battle Of Fredricksburg (My Nam Is America)
- NAM SENSE: Surviving Vietnam with the 101st Airborne Division
Books Index
Books Home
Recommended Books
- Health Psychology: An Introduction to Behavior and Health
- Traveling Mercies: Some Thoughts on Faith
- Methods in Insect Sensory Neuroscience
- Plant Virology Protocols: From Virus Isolation to Transgenic Resistance
- Richard Meier: The Getty Center
- Using Flash MX to Create e-Learning
- The Joe Leaphorn Mysteries: Three Classic Hillerman Mysteries Featuring Lt. Joe Leaphorn: The Blessi
- Preserving Cultural Landscapes in America
- Planning Using Primavera SureTrak Project Manager Version 3.0
- Ascomyceten auf Ericaceen in den Ostalpen